| Award Year | Recipient | Class |
| 2023 | Melisa Alves | 2006 |
| 2023 | Ann Marie Connolly | 1974 |
| 2023 | Edwin P. Petrazzolo | 1969 |
| 2023 | Thomas J. Neagle | 1970 |
| 2022 | Rodney V. De Leaver | 1974 |
| 2022 | Brian P. Duggan | 1996 |
| 2022 | John J. Mahoney, Jr. | 1973 |
| 2022 | Nancy Maddi Taylor | 1981 |
| 2021 | Bryan J. Dimare | 2006 |
| 2021 | Elaine Amodeo DiMase | 1984 |
| 2021 | Schone L. Malliet | 1974 |
| 2021 | Danita Beck Wickwire | 1994 |
| 2020 | William F. Bagley, Jr. | 1973 |
| 2020 | James F. Delehaunty | 1967 |
| 2020 | John J. Murphy | 1973 |
| 2020 | Kimberly A. Stone | 1990 |
| 2019 | Rabbi Norman M. Cohen | 1972 |
| 2019 | Stephen J. Kelleher | 1971 |
| 2019 | Kathleen Taylor Connolly | 1977 |
| 2019 | Michael J. Toner | 1963 |
| 2018 | Hon. Orion L. Douglass | 1968 |
| 2018 | Coleen M. Lynch | 1995 |
| 2018 | Kenneth M. Padgett | 1966 |
| 2018 | James E. Sparkes | 1971 |
| 2017 | Colleen M. Doern | 1989 |
| 2017 | Ronald T. Maheu | 1964 |
| 2017 | Thomas F. McCabe | 1965 |
| 2017 | The Honorable Harry K. Thomas | 1978 |
| 2016 | D. Timothy Buckley | 1959 |
| 2016 | P. Kevin Condron | 1967 |
| 2016 | Maureen E. Moran | 1989 |
| 2016 | Timothy L. Porter | 1968 |
| 2015 | Lawrence W. Doyle | 1983 |
| 2015 | John P. Hamill | 1961 |
| 2015 | Ronald R. Lawson | 1975 |
| 2015 | Elizabeth Stevens Murdy | 1981 |
| 2014 | Colleen F. Amann | 1992 |
| 2014 | Stephen A. Lovelette | 1978 |
| 2014 | Jack D. Rehm | 1954 |
| 2014 | John P. Sindoni | 1967 |
| 2013 | Constance A. Eagan | 1981 |
| 2013 | David J. Martel | 1965 |
| 2013 | Brian A. O'Connell | 1971 |
| 2013 | Francis X. Stankard | 1953 |
| 2012 | John P. Brogan | 1966 |
| 2012 | George M. Ford | 1960 |
| 2012 | William J. Supple | 1981 |
| 2012 | Mark W. Powers | 1985 |
| 2011 | John R. Hayes | 1991 |
| 2011 | Kathleen Troidle Jackson | 1983 |
| 2011 | Gregory H. Cahill | 1981 |
| 2010 | Brian A. Cashman | 1977 |
| 2010 | Michael F. Collins, M.D. | 1977 |
| 2010 | Rev. George L. O'Brien | 1954 |
| 2009 | Frank J. Geischecker | 1953 |
| 2009 | Rev. Thomas P. Henehan, MM | 1960 |
| 2009 | Paula M. Murphy | 1976 |
| 2008 | Robert J. Credle | 1965 |
| 2008 | Thomas E. Ryan | 1976 |
| 2008 | Marcy M. Vandale | 1987 |
| 2007 | Lee F. Bartlett Jr. | 1942 |
| 2007 | Raymond A. Nothnagle | 1957 |
| 2007 | William A. Dempsey | 1963 |
| 2006 | Hon. John J. Moynihan | 1952 |
| 2006 | Frank J. Lasch | 1954 |
| 2006 | Hon. John J. Farley III | 1964 |
| 2005 | Richard B. Fisher | 1947 |
| 2005 | Paul T. McEnery, M.D. | 1960 |
| 2005 | Martha M. McGuane | 1977 |
| 2004 | Richard C. Browne | 1960 |
| 2004 | Mary Ellen Eagan | 1975 |
| 2004 | John P. Glowik Jr. | 1973 |
| 2003 | Charles J. Buchta | 1963 |
| 2003 | Charles E.F. Millard | 1954 |
| 2003 | Stanley A. Slowick | 1974 |
| 2002 | John M. Flavan | 1953 |
| 2002 | Robert P. Trudel | 1964 |
| 2002 | David A. Doern | 1962 |
| 2001 | Paul V. Mullaney | 1942 |
| 2001 | Francis J. McCabe Jr. | 1945 |
| 2001 | Richard L. Ahern | 1951 |
| 2000 | Gerald M. Earls | 1940 |
| 2000 | Richard F. Gibbons | 1960 |
| 2000 | Michael H. Shanahan | 1978 |
| 1999 | Robert J. O'Brien | 1948 |
| 1999 | Joseph F. Whalen | 1952 |
| 1999 | Anne Reilly Ziaja | 1978 |
| 1998 | John F. Becker | 1948 |
| 1998 | William B. McManus | 1958 |
| 1998 | George J. White | 1939 |
| 1997 | James M. Mahoney | 1937 |
| 1997 | William P. Maloney | 1959 |
| 1997 | Thomas N. Troidle | 1959 |
| 1996 | George E. Young Sr. | 1946 |
| 1996 | William E. McKenna | 1947 |
| 1996 | Dennis C. Golden | 1963 |
| 1995 | Walter B. O'Neil | 1940 |
| 1995 | Robert F. Danahy | 1955 |
| 1995 | John F. Mee | 1965 |
| 1994 | Robert J. Leary | 1949 |
| 1994 | Henry C. Lemire | 1954 |
| 1994 | Walter B. Roy | 1972 |
| 1993 | John A. Mahoney | 1948 |
| 1993 | Braden A. Mechley | 1958 |
| 1993 | Richard M. Peirce | 1967 |
| 1992 | Paul F. Coveney | 1955 |
| 1992 | Edward J. Devine | 1942 |
| 1992 | William P. Walsh | 1952 |
| 1991 | Donal J. Burns | 1949 |
| 1991 | Thomas T. Doherty Sr. | 1941 |
| 1991 | James E. Mulvihill, D.M.D. | 1962 |
| 1990 | William A. Eagan Jr. | 1949 |
| 1990 | Edward A. Kennedy Jr. | 1934 |
| 1990 | William F. McCall Jr. | 1955 |
| 1989 | Charles A. Abdella | 1964 |
| 1989 | Albert E. Block | 1954 |
| 1989 | Adrian P. Driggs | 1938 |
| 1988 | Arthur J. Andreoli | 1958 |
| 1988 | George F. Cahill | 1949 |
| 1988 | Paul F.X. Powers | 1938 |
| 1987 | Francis B. Garvey | 1935 |
| 1987 | John F. Havens | 1949 |
| 1987 | Joseph J. Reilly Jr. | 1955 |
| 1986 | Most Rev. Timothy J. Harrington | 1941 |
| 1986 | John W. Kershaw | 1960 |
| 1986 | Richard E. Onofrey | 1955 |
| 1985 | Richard R. Delfino | 1960 |
| 1985 | Charles E. Downs | 1930 |
| 1985 | George F. McDonough | 1929 |
| 1984 | Thomas C. McKone | 1940 |
| 1984 | Joseph I. Mulligan | 1934 |
| 1984 | Martin J. O'Malley | 1926 |
| 1983 | Gerald R. Anderson, CLU | 1938 |
| 1983 | Kevin J. Collins, Esq. | 1961 |
| 1983 | John F. Moriarty Jr. | 1936 |
| 1982 | William J. Casey | 1952 |
| 1982 | Andrew H. Creen | 1936 |
| 1982 | Thomas P O'Boyle | 1942 |
| 1981 | Most Rev. Bernard J. Flanagan | 1928 |
| 1981 | Philip R. Byrne | 1935 |
| 1980 | Hon. John P. Cooney | 1923 |
| 1980 | Barry R. McDonough | 1954 |
| 1980 | Angelo J. Picone | 1946 |
| 1979 | Donald F. Collins | 1949 |
| 1979 | Robert R. Massa | 1949 |
| 1979 | Edward A. O'Rorke | 1929 |
| 1978 | C. Keefe Hurley | 1929 |
| 1978 | E. Corbett Walsh | 1928 |
| 1978 | Joseph A. King | 1935 |
| 1977 | George A. Cashman | 1947 |
| 1977 | Joseph J. Fay | 1932 |
| 1977 | Donald W. Karal | 1949 |
| 1976 | James F. Coburn Jr. | 1946 |
| 1976 | Peter J. McGrath | 1929 |
| 1976 | Hon. Angelo G. Santaniello | 1946 |
| 1975 | Philip E. O'Connell | 1932 |
| 1975 | Paul F. Saint | 1940 |
| 1974 | Martin B. Murray, MD | 1933 |
| 1974 | Justin J. Murphy | 1929 |
| 1974 | John J. Costello | 1930 |
| 1973 | Charles J.E. Kickham | 1923 |
| 1972 | John J. McDonald, MD | 1942 |
| 1972 | Henry M. Mannix, MD | 1947 |
| 1972 | John J. McNally | 1950 |
| 1971 | Richard T. Langan | 1926 |
| 1971 | George F. Havens | 1931 |
| 1971 | John J. Ryan | 1941 |
| 1970 | Joseph V. Aieta | 1940 |
| 1970 | Edward A. Dinneen | 1920 |
| 1969 | William J. Sullivan | 1924 |
| 1969 | C. Clark Hodgson | 1927 |
| 1969 | Edward J. O'Connell | 1934 |
| 1968 | Thomas B. Dowd | 1923 |
| 1968 | Edmund J. Fitzgerald | 1928 |
| 1967 | George F. Dinneen | 1937 |
| 1967 | Joseph H. Driscoll | 1927 |
| 1966 | Austin W. Keane | 1947 |
| 1966 | Thomas H. Smith | 1946 |
| 1965 | John F. Beakey, MD | 1940 |
| 1965 | Lawrence M. Kearns | 1935 |
| 1964 | James F. Donnelly | 1899 |
| 1964 | Timothy J. Collins Jr. | 1933 |
| 1963 | Thomas W. Wickham, MD | 1909 |
| 1963 | Msgr. John J. Finn | 1907 |
| 1963 | William M. Cousins Jr. | 1945 |
| 1962 | Henry M. Hogan | 1918 |
| 1962 | J. Frank Morris | 1933 |
| 1962 | J. Clement McCann | 1935 |
| 1961 | George B. Moran | 1933 |
| 1961 | Myles F. Costello | 1920 |
| 1961 | Gerald V. Clarke | 1930 |
| 1960 | Charles J. Fleming | 1918 |
| 1960 | Bernard W. Feeny | 1909 |
| 1960 | Francis J. Vaas | 1938 |